Has a non-compete clause been breached?
Find out how a private investigator can conduct enquiries and gather evidence to help protect your business.
When a former employee joins a competing company or develops an activity that may harm the interests of their former employer, compliance with a non-compete clause can quickly become a major issue.
However, it is still necessary to establish the reality of that activity and gather evidence that can be relied upon. In this context, a private investigator can carry out targeted and proportionate enquiries in order to document any potential breaches.
where an employer suspects that a former employee is failing to comply with a non-compete clause, a private investigator may investigate and document their actual activity. Enquiries may combine field surveillance, administrative checks and analysis of digital sources. The evidence gathered can then be reviewed with the company’s solicitor as part of the appropriate legal proceedings.
What is a non-compete clause?
A non-compete clause is a provision included by an employer in an employment contract in order to restrict an employee’s freedom, after termination of the contract, to carry out equivalent duties for a competitor or on their own account.
Such a clause is only lawful if it is necessary to protect the company’s legitimate interests. It is therefore a way for a business owner to protect the company’s security, confidential interests and know-how.
According to the well-known judgment of the French Cour de cassation dated 10 July 2002, No. 00-45.387, a non-compete clause must satisfy four cumulative conditions in order to be valid:
- Limited in time: its duration must not be excessive.
- Limited geographically: a specific geographical area must be defined, such as a town, department or region.
- Limited to specifically identified activities: it must concern activities that are genuinely capable of harming the former employer.
- It must include financial compensation for the employee: the employee must receive financial consideration in exchange for the restriction.
Who can lawfully establish a breach of a non-compete clause?
The employer is the primary party affected by a breach of the employment contract.
However, the law strictly regulates the way in which evidence may be gathered. Surveillance carried out directly by the employer may raise issues concerning privacy and the lawfulness of the evidence obtained.
Instructing a professional investigator helps ensure that enquiries are carried out in accordance with the principles of necessity and proportionality.
A private investigator is an independent professional licensed by the CNAPS and authorised to produce an investigation report.
This report may constitute lawful evidence capable of being submitted before the French Commercial Courts or the Conseil de prud’hommes (Employment Tribunal), although its evidential value remains a matter for the judge to determine.
Who can instruct a private investigator to prove a breach of a non-compete clause?
A company with a legitimate interest may instruct a private investigation agency to verify facts that may amount to a breach of the clause.
The enquiries must comply with employment law. The investigation must be justified by the need to protect the company’s legitimate interests and must remain proportionate to the objective pursued.
What can a private investigator do to prove a breach of a non-compete clause?
A private investigator may carry out several types of enquiries.
Field enquiries: discreet surveillance and observation may be used to establish the former employee’s actual activity, such as meetings with clients, deliveries of goods or presence at the premises of a competing business.
Administrative enquiries: checks may be carried out into the existence of shell companies, company appointments or contractual links with new employers.
Digital monitoring: professional social networks and business directories may be analysed in order to identify relevant public information.
Why instruct a private investigator to prove a breach of a non-compete clause?
The intervention of a private investigator can help gather evidence of non-compliance with a non-compete clause.
This evidence may be used directly in litigation or, for example, to support an application for an ex parte court order or for the intervention of a commissaire de justice in order to preserve evidence before it disappears, pursuant to Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.
The intervention of a private investigator may therefore help bring an end to acts of unfair competition and support a claim for compensation corresponding to the financial loss suffered by the business.
Example: a company learns that a former sales employee, who is subject to a non-compete clause, may be working for a competing business located within the prohibited geographical area.
An investigation may establish whether this activity is genuine by documenting, for example, regular attendance at the competitor’s premises, professional meetings, visits to clients or other objective facts.
The investigation report can then help the company and its legal adviser assess what further action should be taken.
How much does a private investigator cost in a non-compete case?
The cost of an investigation cannot be determined in advance without first reviewing the circumstances of the case.
The price will depend on factors such as:
- the number of surveillance hours required;
- the complexity of the administrative enquiries;
- travel and other associated expenses.
We always offer an initial review of your case free of charge.
Following this discussion, you will be provided with either a fixed-fee quotation or an hourly-rate proposal.
It should also be remembered that, if legal proceedings are successful, an application may be made to the court for reimbursement of some of the investigation costs as legal expenses under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, although reimbursement is not guaranteed.
FAQ : Frequently Asked Questions About Non-Compete Clauses
How can you prove that a former employee is working for a competitor?
Evidence may consist of several consistent factors, such as attendance at a workplace, professional meetings, travel connected with business activity or publicly available online activity.
A private investigator may carry out enquiries in order to document this activity objectively.
Can a private investigator monitor a former employee?
Yes, where there is a legitimate interest in checking compliance with a non-compete clause.
However, the investigation must remain necessary and proportionate to the objective pursued and must respect the individual’s right to privacy.
Is a private investigator’s report admissible before the Employment Tribunal?
A private investigation report may be submitted in proceedings before the Conseil de prud’hommes.
Its admissibility and evidential weight are, however, assessed by the judge, particularly in light of the circumstances in which the evidence was obtained.
How long does surveillance need to continue in order to prove a breach?
There is no standard duration.
Surveillance must be adapted to the circumstances and must be long enough to establish objective facts, while remaining proportionate to the purpose of the investigation.
Who pays the private investigator’s fees if there are legal proceedings?
The company instructing the private investigator initially pays the fees.
If legal proceedings follow, the company may ask the judge to award a contribution towards those costs under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, although there is no guarantee that all costs incurred will be reimbursed.